Freemium and free trials are two ways of letting people try your product before they pay. Which one brings in more money is not a question with one answer for every product. It depends on five numbers you can find or estimate, and one cost that is easy to forget: what it costs you to serve the people who never pay.
The funnel in three steps
Both models follow the same three steps:
- Visitors sign up. A share of the people who visit your site create an account.
- Signups become paying customers. A share of those who signed up end up paying.
- Paying customers stay for a while. They pay until they cancel.
Freemium usually gets more people to sign up (there is no deadline or card), but fewer of them pay. A free trial usually gets fewer signups, but a larger share of them pay. How big those gaps are differs a lot from one product to another, so the numbers below are round examples, not benchmarks. Use your own.
What a paying customer is worth
If a customer pays 30 a month, your gross margin is 80%, and 4% of paying customers cancel each month, the average customer brings in:
price × gross margin ÷ monthly churn = 30 × 0.80 ÷ 0.04 = 600
of gross profit over their time with you. This is the usual lifetime value formula, using gross profit rather than revenue.
The cost people forget
A free user is not free to serve. They use storage, support time, email and server capacity. If you have a free plan, every signup who never pays still costs you something. The size of that cost depends on your product, so the comparison below lets you set it.
A worked example
Take 10,000 visitors in a month, a price of 30, an 80% margin and 4% monthly churn for paying customers (so each paying customer is worth 600). Both models use the same numbers, but the funnel is different.
Freemium: 10% of visitors sign up, 3% of signups pay, and each free user who never pays costs 1.00 to serve.
Free trial: 5% of visitors sign up, 20% of signups pay, and each trial user who never pays costs 0.20 to serve.
| Freemium | Free trial | |
|---|---|---|
| Signups | 1,000 | 500 |
| Paying customers | 30 | 100 |
| Share of visitors who pay | 0.3% | 1.0% |
| Gross profit from paying customers (30 or 100 × 600) | 18,000 | 60,000 |
| Signups who never pay | 970 | 400 |
| Cost of serving them | 970 | 80 |
| Net (lifetime gross profit minus serving cost) | 17,030 | 59,920 |
On these numbers the trial is ahead by 42,890. These figures are the lifetime gross profit of one month’s signups, not a monthly amount.
What would have to change for freemium to win
Cutting the cost of free users helps, but only so far. With these numbers, even if free users cost nothing to serve, freemium earns 18,000, still well below the trial’s 59,920. No serving cost can close the gap, because the shortfall is in how few free users pay.
| Cost to serve each free user who never pays | Freemium net | Free trial net |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 18,000 | 59,920 |
| 1 | 17,030 | 59,920 |
| 5 | 13,150 | 59,920 |
| 10 | 8,300 | 59,920 |
Now change the funnel instead. Suppose freemium brings in twice as many signups (20% of visitors) and 6% of them pay:
| Freemium | Free trial | |
|---|---|---|
| Signups | 2,000 | 500 |
| Paying customers | 120 | 100 |
| Net | 70,120 | 59,920 |
Freemium now wins by 10,200. But it only keeps winning while the cost of serving each free user who never pays stays below about 6.43. Above that, the trial is ahead again. At 5% of signups paying instead of 6% (100 paying customers, same as the trial), freemium would be behind: 58,100 against 59,920.
The lesson is not that one model is better. It is that a small change in a funnel rate or in serving cost can flip the answer, so it is worth testing with your own figures.
What this does not tell you
- Whether your rates look like the example. They are round numbers chosen to illustrate the method.
- Differences between customers. It treats every paying customer as worth the same lifetime gross profit. Customers from a free plan and from a trial may behave differently.
- Costs beyond serving. It ignores sales effort, support for paying customers beyond the gross margin, expansion revenue and how long it takes people to convert.
- Timing. The net figure is a lifetime total for one month’s signups. It does not show when the money arrives.
- What suits your product. A product that needs time to show its value, or that is only useful in a team, can change the answer in ways a funnel does not capture.
Try it with your own numbers
The freemium vs free trial comparator lets you enter your visitors, price, margin, signup and paid rates, churn and the cost of serving free users for each model, and shows which comes out ahead and the serving cost at which freemium would catch up.
The tool opens with its own example numbers. To reproduce the worked example above, enter 10,000 visitors, a price of 30 and a margin of 80%. For freemium, enter 10% signups, 3% paying, 4% churn and a cost of 1.00. For the free trial, enter 5% signups, 20% paying, 4% churn and a cost of 0.20.
Sources
- Sybill: Freemium vs Free Trial (the funnel steps; free users are not free to serve)
- ChartMogul: Customer lifetime value (lifetime value formula)
W
Written by the Webtilly team