| One month’s visitors | Freemium | Free trial |
|---|
How to use it
- Enter your visitors a month, your monthly price and your gross margin.
- For each model, enter the share of visitors who sign up, the share of signups who become paying customers, monthly churn after they pay, and what it costs you to serve each signup who never pays.
- The two buttons fill in the free trial rates for a trial without a card and a trial with a card. Read the big number first: it is the difference between the two models, and the label says which one is ahead.
The numbers in the boxes when the page loads are examples, not a forecast. The signup and paid rates come from a survey as reported second-hand (see Sources), and the serving costs are placeholders. Replace all of them with your own.
The math, shown
Each model turns visitors into signups, signups into paying customers, and then subtracts what it costs to serve the signups who never pay.
Net = gross profit from paying customers − cost of serving signups who never pay
Signups. Visitors × the share who sign up.
Paying customers. Signups × the share who become paid. The rest are signups who never pay.
Lifetime gross profit per paying customer. Price × gross margin ÷ monthly churn. This is the same lifetime value formula as on the LTV calculator.
Gross profit from paying customers. Paying customers × the lifetime gross profit above.
Cost of serving signups who never pay. Those signups × the cost per signup you enter.
Break-even serving cost for freemium. (freemium gross profit − trial net) ÷ freemium signups who never pay. It is shown only when freemium’s gross profit is higher than the trial’s net.
The funnel arithmetic and lifetime value formula are standard (see Sources). Combining them into a net figure and the break-even serving cost are Webtilly’s own.
Worked example
10,000 visitors a month, price 30, gross margin 80%, churn 4% in both models.
- Lifetime gross profit per paying customer: 30 × 0.80 ÷ 0.04 = 600.
- Freemium (13.3% sign up, 2.6% of them pay, 1.50 to serve each non-payer): 1,330 signups, 34.58 paying, 1,295.42 who never pay. Gross profit 34.58 × 600 = 20,748. Serving cost 1,295.42 × 1.50 = 1,943.13. Net 18,804.87.
- Free trial (8.5% sign up, 18.2% pay, 0.20 to serve each non-payer): 850 signups, 154.7 paying, 695.3 who never pay. Gross profit 154.7 × 600 = 92,820. Serving cost 695.3 × 0.20 = 139.06. Net 92,680.94.
- The trial is ahead by 73,876.07. Freemium’s gross profit (20,748) is below the trial’s net, so no serving cost would let freemium catch up.
How to read your result
The result is only as good as the rates you enter. Funnel rates differ a lot from one product to another, so the example result says little about yours. The table underneath shows every step, so you can see which rate or cost drives the difference.
The note under the big number says whether any serving cost would let freemium catch up, or how much each non-payer can cost before freemium stops being ahead.
What this tool leaves out
- It treats every paying customer as worth the same lifetime gross profit.
- It ignores sales effort, support cost for paying customers beyond the gross margin, expansion revenue, and the delay before people convert.
- It shows the result of the numbers you enter, not which model is better in general.
Frequently asked questions
Where do the example rates come from?
The signup and paid rates in the boxes are reported by Sybill as coming from a First Page Sage survey of 86 SaaS companies. We did not open the original, so treat them as second-hand examples, not benchmarks. The serving costs (1.50 and 0.20) are placeholders we chose, not data. Replace all of them with your own.
Why does the tool need churn above 0%?
Lifetime value is gross profit per month ÷ churn. At 0% churn that divides by zero, which has no finite answer, so the tool asks for a figure above 0%.
What is the break-even serving cost?
It is the most freemium can afford to spend on each signup who never pays and still match the trial. In the second example in our checks (freemium paid rate 12%, serving cost 0.50, trial paid rate 3%) freemium comes out ahead by 80,040 and stays ahead while each such signup costs less than 68.89 to serve. When freemium is behind even at zero cost, the tool says so and shows no figure.
Sources
- Sybill: freemium vs free trial
- ChartMogul, Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)
- Webtilly’s own: the net figure, the serving cost and the break-even serving cost.
W
Written by the Webtilly team
Note: This tool shows the result of the numbers you enter. It is an estimate, not a forecast, and it is not tax, legal, or financial advice.