Annual vs monthly billing: how big a discount can you afford?

Offering a discount for paying a year up front sounds like a good trade: you get cash earlier and customers commit for longer. But a discount is revenue you give up. Whether it pays depends on two things you can estimate: how many monthly customers leave each month, and how many annual customers renew at the end of the year.

What a discount really gives away

A plan at 100 a month, sold at 80 a month when paid yearly, is 20% off: 960 for the year instead of 1,200. The yearly buyer pays for 9.6 months and gets 12. In general, a discount of 20% is the same as 2.4 free months.

So the question is not “is 20% fair?” but “how many extra months of payment do I get in return?”

What monthly churn does to a year of monthly revenue

A monthly customer can leave at any time. If 5% leave each month, the average customer does not pay for all 12 months. Counting a customer as paying for the month they join and then possibly leaving, the average monthly customer pays for about 9.2 months in the first year (5% churn) and 14.2 months over two years.

After 12 months, about 54% of a group of monthly customers are still paying (0.95 to the power of 12).

An annual customer has paid for the whole year in advance. The risk moves from “leaving in month 4” to “not renewing in month 13”.

A worked example

Assume these example figures. They are made up for the illustration, not benchmarks:

  • Monthly price: 50
  • Annual plan: 20% off, so 480 a year (40 a month, 2.4 free months)
  • Monthly churn on the monthly plan: 5%
  • Share of annual customers who renew each year: 70%
  • Horizon: 2 years

Monthly plan: an average customer pays for 14.16 months over two years, so brings in about 708.01.

Annual plan: an average customer pays 480 in year 1, and 70% of them pay another 480 in year 2: 480 + 336 = 816.00.

On these figures the annual plan earns more per customer, 816.00 against 708.01, even with the 20% discount. If you look at the first year alone, the annual plan collects 480 against 459.64 from the monthly plan.

The biggest discount that still earns the same

Turn the question around: what discount makes the two plans earn exactly the same over the two years?

With these figures it is 30.59%. Give more than that and the annual plan earns less than the monthly plan; give less and it earns more.

This is our own calculation, not a published formula. It sets the revenue from a monthly customer, 50 times the average number of paid months, equal to the revenue from an annual customer, the annual price times the average number of paid years.

How it changes with churn

Same example (50 a month, 20% off, 70% renewal, two years), only monthly churn changes. The annual plan earns 816.00 per customer in every row, because monthly churn does not affect it:

Monthly churnMonthly plan earns (2 years)Biggest discount that still earns the same
2%960.555.83%
5%708.0130.59%
8%540.5147.01%

The pattern is clear. The more monthly customers you lose, the more the annual plan is worth, and the bigger the discount you can afford. When monthly churn is low (2% here), a 20% discount costs you: the monthly plan would earn 960.55 against 816.00.

What this does not tell you

  • Whether your numbers look like the example. The 5% churn and 70% renewal are illustrations. Use your own.
  • Who picks which plan. The calculation assumes the same kind of customer chooses either plan. In practice, customers who choose to pay yearly may already be more committed, which can flatter the annual plan.
  • Cash timing. It does not put a value on getting 480 today instead of 50 a month. Cash earlier is worth something; the calculation ignores it.
  • Fees, tax and failed payments. It uses revenue, not profit, and assumes every payment goes through.
  • Anything beyond three years. It compares one, two or three years only.

Try it with your own numbers

The billing term planner lets you enter your monthly price, discount, monthly churn and yearly renewal rate, and shows what each plan earns and the biggest discount that still breaks even.

Sources

  1. Dodo Payments: Annual vs Monthly Billing for SaaS (opens in a new tab) (the discount arithmetic)
  2. ChartMogul: Billing cycles (opens in a new tab)
  3. The break-even discount calculation is Webtilly’s own.

W

Written by the Webtilly team

Formula and sources last checked: 24th Oct 2026 · How we check our work