Annual vs monthly billing planner

Find the biggest annual-plan discount that still earns as much per customer as monthly billing. Enter your price, churn and renewal rate. Formulas and sources shown.

Compare over
$
%
%
%
1 − paid months ÷ (12 × paid years)—
Biggest annual discount that still earns as much as monthly billing
30.59%
What an average customer brings in
The biggest-discount figure is Webtilly’s own calculation, not a published formula: it sets the revenue from a monthly customer (price × average paid months) equal to the revenue from an annual customer (annual price × average paid years). A monthly customer pays for a month and then may leave. It uses revenue, not profit, and no payment fees or tax. It assumes churn and renewal stay the same and that the same kind of customer chooses either plan (people who pick annual may already be more committed). It ignores failed payments and the value of receiving cash earlier.

How to use it

  1. Enter the monthly price and the annual discount you are thinking of.
  2. Enter your monthly churn on the monthly plan, and the share of annual customers who renew each year.
  3. Choose how many years to compare: 1, 2 or 3. Read the big number first: it is the biggest discount that still earns the same on both plans.

The numbers in the boxes when the page loads are examples, not a forecast. Replace them with your own.

The math, shown

A monthly customer can leave at any time, and an annual customer pays for a year at once. The planner counts how many months a typical customer pays on each plan, and what that is worth.

Biggest discount = 1 − paid months on the monthly plan ÷ (12 × paid years on the annual plan)

Annual price. 12 × monthly price × (1 − discount). At 20% off a price of 50, that is 480, or 40 a month, which is 2.4 months free.

Paid months, monthly plan. Over n months, (1 − (1 − c)^n) ÷ c, where c is monthly churn. A customer pays for a month, then may leave. At 5% churn over 24 months this is 14.16.

Paid years, annual plan. Over N years, (1 − r^N) ÷ (1 − r), where r is the share who renew each year. At 70% renewal over 2 years this is 1.7.

Earnings per customer. Monthly price × paid months on the monthly plan; annual price × paid years on the annual plan.

Also shown. The effective monthly price, the free months equivalent, the share of monthly customers still paying after 12 months ((1 − c)^12), and cash collected in the first year on each plan.

The “biggest discount” is Webtilly’s own calculation, not a published formula. The annual discount and effective monthly price are standard (see Sources).

Worked example

Price 50, 20% off, 5% monthly churn, 70% renewal, 2 years.

  • Monthly plan: 50 × 14.16 = 708.01 per customer.
  • Annual plan: 480 × 1.7 = 816.00 per customer. The annual plan is ahead by 107.99.
  • Biggest discount: 1 − 14.16 ÷ (12 × 1.7) = 1 − 14.16 ÷ 20.4 = 30.59%. A discount above that makes the annual plan earn less.
  • In the first year alone, the monthly plan collects 459.64 per customer against 480.00 for the annual plan, and 54.04% of monthly customers are still paying after 12 months.

How to read your result

The big number is a limit: the deepest discount at which the annual plan still earns as much as the monthly plan, on the churn and renewal rates you entered. A discount below it earns more on the annual plan; above it, less. A longer comparison period changes the answer, because churn and renewal compound differently over time.

We give no figure for a normal annual discount or a normal renewal rate, because we have no source for one. Use your own churn and renewal figures.

What this tool leaves out

  • It uses revenue, not profit, and no payment fees or tax.
  • It assumes churn and renewal rates stay the same, and that the same kind of customer picks either plan. In practice people who choose annual may already be more committed.
  • It ignores failed payments and the value of getting cash earlier, and it does not discount future money.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the biggest discount 0% when there is no churn?

If monthly customers never leave, a monthly customer pays 12 full months a year, so any discount on the annual plan earns less. Set churn to 0% and renewal to 100% with a 1-year period to see it.

Why does the renewal rate make no difference over 1 year?

In the first year every annual customer has paid the full annual price, whatever happens later. Renewal only affects the second and third years.

Is the “biggest discount” a published formula?

No. It is Webtilly’s own calculation, built from the paid-months and paid-years arithmetic above. The annual discount and effective monthly price are standard. Check the result against your own billing data before you rely on it.

Sources

  1. Dodo Payments: annual vs monthly billing for SaaS (opens in a new tab) (annual discount and effective monthly price)
  2. Webtilly’s own: the paid-months and paid-years calculations and the “biggest discount”.

W

Written by the Webtilly team

Formula and sources last checked: 24th Oct 2026 · How we check our work

Note: This tool shows the result of the numbers you enter. It is an estimate, not a forecast, and it is not tax, legal, or financial advice.