How to use it
- Enter the monthly price and the annual discount you are thinking of.
- Enter your monthly churn on the monthly plan, and the share of annual customers who renew each year.
- Choose how many years to compare: 1, 2 or 3. Read the big number first: it is the biggest discount that still earns the same on both plans.
The numbers in the boxes when the page loads are examples, not a forecast. Replace them with your own.
The math, shown
A monthly customer can leave at any time, and an annual customer pays for a year at once. The planner counts how many months a typical customer pays on each plan, and what that is worth.
Biggest discount = 1 − paid months on the monthly plan ÷ (12 × paid years on the annual plan)
Annual price. 12 × monthly price × (1 − discount). At 20% off a price of 50, that is 480, or 40 a month, which is 2.4 months free.
Paid months, monthly plan. Over n months, (1 − (1 − c)^n) ÷ c, where c is monthly churn. A customer pays for a month, then may leave. At 5% churn over 24 months this is 14.16.
Paid years, annual plan. Over N years, (1 − r^N) ÷ (1 − r), where r is the share who renew each year. At 70% renewal over 2 years this is 1.7.
Earnings per customer. Monthly price × paid months on the monthly plan; annual price × paid years on the annual plan.
Also shown. The effective monthly price, the free months equivalent, the share of monthly customers still paying after 12 months ((1 − c)^12), and cash collected in the first year on each plan.
The “biggest discount” is Webtilly’s own calculation, not a published formula. The annual discount and effective monthly price are standard (see Sources).
Worked example
Price 50, 20% off, 5% monthly churn, 70% renewal, 2 years.
- Monthly plan: 50 × 14.16 = 708.01 per customer.
- Annual plan: 480 × 1.7 = 816.00 per customer. The annual plan is ahead by 107.99.
- Biggest discount: 1 − 14.16 ÷ (12 × 1.7) = 1 − 14.16 ÷ 20.4 = 30.59%. A discount above that makes the annual plan earn less.
- In the first year alone, the monthly plan collects 459.64 per customer against 480.00 for the annual plan, and 54.04% of monthly customers are still paying after 12 months.
How to read your result
The big number is a limit: the deepest discount at which the annual plan still earns as much as the monthly plan, on the churn and renewal rates you entered. A discount below it earns more on the annual plan; above it, less. A longer comparison period changes the answer, because churn and renewal compound differently over time.
We give no figure for a normal annual discount or a normal renewal rate, because we have no source for one. Use your own churn and renewal figures.
What this tool leaves out
- It uses revenue, not profit, and no payment fees or tax.
- It assumes churn and renewal rates stay the same, and that the same kind of customer picks either plan. In practice people who choose annual may already be more committed.
- It ignores failed payments and the value of getting cash earlier, and it does not discount future money.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the biggest discount 0% when there is no churn?
If monthly customers never leave, a monthly customer pays 12 full months a year, so any discount on the annual plan earns less. Set churn to 0% and renewal to 100% with a 1-year period to see it.
Why does the renewal rate make no difference over 1 year?
In the first year every annual customer has paid the full annual price, whatever happens later. Renewal only affects the second and third years.
Is the “biggest discount” a published formula?
No. It is Webtilly’s own calculation, built from the paid-months and paid-years arithmetic above. The annual discount and effective monthly price are standard. Check the result against your own billing data before you rely on it.
Sources
- Dodo Payments: annual vs monthly billing for SaaS (annual discount and effective monthly price)
- Webtilly’s own: the paid-months and paid-years calculations and the “biggest discount”.
W
Written by the Webtilly team
Note: This tool shows the result of the numbers you enter. It is an estimate, not a forecast, and it is not tax, legal, or financial advice.