CAC payback tells you how many months it takes a new customer to earn back what you spent to win them. A short payback means your acquisition spend comes back quickly. A long one means you are lending money to your customers for a long time. This article shows the formula, a worked example and what happens when some customers leave before they have paid you back.
Start with CAC
Customer acquisition cost (CAC) is what you spent on sales and marketing to win new customers, divided by how many new customers you won in the same period.
CAC = sales and marketing spend ÷ new customers
If you spent 5,600 in a month and won 10 customers, CAC is 560 each. (There is a CAC calculator on this site.)
Why gross profit, not revenue
A customer paying 50 a month does not bring in 50 of spare money. Some of it goes on the direct cost of serving them: hosting, support, payment fees. What is left is gross profit. At an 80% gross margin, a 50-a-month customer brings in 40 a month.
Payback should be measured against gross profit, because gross profit is what pays back the acquisition cost.
The formula
CAC payback (months) = CAC ÷ (monthly revenue per customer × gross margin)
This is the same as total spend ÷ (new monthly revenue × gross margin), if you only have totals.
A worked example
You spent 5,600 on sales and marketing in a month and won 10 customers. Each pays 50 a month. Gross margin is 80%.
| Step | Result |
|---|---|
| CAC | 5,600 ÷ 10 = 560 |
| Gross profit per customer per month | 50 × 0.80 = 40 |
| Payback | 560 ÷ 40 = 14 months |
The totals version gives the same answer: 5,600 ÷ (500 new monthly revenue × 0.80) = 14 months.
Another way to see it: if you spend 50,000 in a quarter and win customers worth 20,000 of new monthly revenue at an 80% margin, payback is 50,000 ÷ (20,000 × 0.80) = 3.125 months.
How margin changes it
Same CAC (560) and price (50), only margin changes:
| Gross margin | Gross profit per month | Payback |
|---|---|---|
| 60% | 30 | 18.67 months |
| 80% | 40 | 14.00 months |
| 90% | 45 | 12.44 months |
A better margin shortens payback without you winning a single extra customer.
What if customers leave before they have paid you back?
The simple formula assumes every customer stays for the whole payback period. In reality some leave. The ones who stay for months pay back the cost; the ones who leave early do not.
Here is one way to allow for it. This is our own method, not a published formula. Take the average new customer, counting the ones who leave, and add up the gross profit they bring in each month until it reaches CAC.
With monthly churn of 3% (3% of customers leave each month), on the same example:
| After | Gross profit recovered so far (of 560) |
|---|---|
| 6 months | 222.70 |
| 12 months | 408.21 |
| 14 months | 462.88 |
| 17 months | 538.90 |
| 18 months | 562.73 |
So payback is not 14 months but about 18 (17.9 by the formula).
With monthly churn of 8%, after 18 months you have recovered only 388.53. And there is a ceiling: an average customer will never bring in more than 40 ÷ 0.08 = 500 of gross profit, which is less than the 560 it cost to win them. On those numbers a customer never pays back.
What this does not tell you
- Whether your payback is good. We give no benchmark: the figures commonly quoted come without a source, and the right answer depends on your business, your cash and your margin.
- Timing of spend. Spend usually comes months before the customers it wins. The formula assumes spend and customers belong to the same period.
- Expansion. New monthly revenue should leave out upgrades from existing customers. The calculation is about new customers only.
- Which customers. Different channels can have very different CACs. Averaging them hides that.
- Churn that changes. The “customers leave” version assumes the same churn rate every month.
Try it with your own numbers
The CAC payback period calculator takes your spend, new customers, revenue per customer and gross margin, and shows CAC and payback. If you also enter monthly churn, it shows the “customers leave” version. To see whether payback is worth it over a customer’s whole life, try the LTV:CAC ratio calculator.
Sources
- Orb: CAC payback (formula and the 50,000 / 20,000 example)
- Wall Street Prep: CAC payback period (formula and the 5,600 / 10 customers example)
- The “customers leave” version is Webtilly’s own.
W
Written by the Webtilly team